Seven years after the first basel committee on banking supervisions. One of the most visible updates to the trading book regime is the revised trading banking book boundary. Banks could decide which was the trading book and which was the banking book and this created incentives to profit from the arbitrage from this determination. Trading and banking book boundary in line with the basel framework, crd 5 proposes a revised boundary between the trading and banking book. Implications and actions for banks nevertheless, a number of banks have expressed the concern that frtb will lead to a significant increase in capital requirements which, combined with higher compliance costs, could decrease banking profitability.
Financial instruments in a trading book are purchased or sold for reasons including to. So far, the banks have been deciding if a book was a trading book or a banking book, and there was an incentive to arbitrage from this determination, as there was a difference in the capital. In this context, stricter limits as well as capital disincentives. To achieve a more robust framework, the basel committee on banking supervision bcbs issued a series of. By continuing to use this site you agree to our use of cookies. The global financial crisis of 2007 and 2008 revealed significant weaknesses in the market risk capital mrc framework. For example, banks could move assets between the banking book and the trading book to minimise the capital charge. Before bcbs come with defined rules for banking book and trading book boundary, currently different banks have setup their on policy to do the same.
The loose definition of the regulatory boundary has been a source of weakness, and banks have been defining the status of a book, based upon their selfdetermined intent to trade. This means revisiting any previous approach to modelling this structure, embedding it in an electronic representation, and ongoing monitoring. Loans and other accrual instruments are presumed to be held to maturity. About 14 firms reported both trading book and banking book positions for the presented list of instruments. The philosophical differences in risk measurement can be. The trading banking book boundary published on february 15, 2016 february 15, 2016 80 likes 11 comments. What you need to know about the new trading boundary. A trading book consists of all instruments that meet the specifications for trading book instruments set out in rbc25. A revised boundary between the trading book and banking book. Implications and actions for banks nevertheless, a number of banks have expressed the concern that frtb will lead to a significant increase in capital requirements which, combined with higher. Since the credit related products were the main source of losses during the 2009 financial crisis, the bis committee has agreed to bring the trading book requirements closer to the banking book. Through the frtb rules, bcbs is seeking, for example, to establish a more objective boundary between the trading book and the banking book, and to eliminate capital arbitrage between the regulatory banking and trading books. Frtb new market risk framework polarizes regulators and.
A revised boundary between the trading book and banking book a revised and standardized approach for market risk. By shearin cao, technical specialist, traded risk management, standard chartered bank. A fundamental objective of frtb is creating a high, impermeable wall that separates the trading and banking books. In its previous form, the boundary between the trading book and the banking book was unclear. Revised trading and banking book boundary for market risk 7 frtb still builds on the intent based criteria for tradingbanking book assignment but supplements it with essential prescriptive rules in order to provide more objectiveness. So here are the definitions on how to treat a position either as a banking book or as a trading book. Criteria for trading banking book boundary include instrument structure, accounting treatment, availability of prices, portfolio, desk, hedge relationship etc. This new boundary framework is an important feature of frtb and represents a major change for many banks trading activities. What are the issues with the classification of the trading book and banking book boundary. Revised boundary between the trading book and banking book banking book positions which are carried at amortized cost and are subject to pillar 2 requirements, does not attract capital charge whereas trading book positions are subject to pillar 1 capital charge and are marked to market, attracting higher market risk capital charges. The financial instruments are grouped under trading book or a banking book depending on the trading intent and valuation of the instruments. One of the most apparent changes to the trading book regime is the revised trading banking book boundary definition. Frtb requires that business be allocated to either the trading or banking book, and not jump the boundary in an arbitrary way.
It was generally agreed that permeability across the tradingbanking book boundary created the opportunity for extreme mismatches between. The boundary is aligned with the banks own risk management practices relative to. Post the 2008 financial crisis, there were multiple regulations issued by the regulatory bodies t. The revised requirements will lead to increased demands on the availability of. This shows the impact of the changes in trading book boundaries. The basel committee on banking supervision designed the framework to remove supposed deficiencies in the previous market risk framework which came to light during the global financial crisis. There has been a lot of discussion on how frtb will define whether a book is a banking book. In general, trading book boundary rules restrict banks to transfer instruments between trading and banking book, specially for the regulatory arbitrage purposes. It also has to document any deviations from the presumptive list in detail on an ongoing basis art. Banks must use sa, unless they meet ima requirements on an ongoing basis, in which case. Separating instruments into banking or trading books.
Frtb still builds on the intent based criteria for tradingbanking book assignment but supplements it with essential prescriptive rules in order to provide more. As a first step towards full implementation of the frtb framework, the. Requirements of the banking book trading book boundary. On larger view below methodology gets followed to classify the book as banking and trading. Real estate holdings and retail and small business lending must go in the banking book. The boundary between the trading book and the banking book. Mar 14, 2017 the boundary between the trading book and banking book needs to be tightly defined. Concepts, implications and implementation risk books. What has changed, what has not, and what the bis does not talk about. Banking trading book boundaryphilosophical differences in risk management. Jun, 2016 in january 2016, the basel committee on banking supervision published its standards for minimum capital requirements for market risk. Basel iv revised trading and banking book boundary for market.
The boundary between trading and banking books under frtb. So far, the banks have been deciding if a book was a trading book or a banking book, and there was an incentive to arbitrage from this determination, as there was a difference in the capital requirements for these books. The frtb, released by the basel committee on banking supervision bcbs in 2016, revised the minimum capital requirements for market risk to address the shortcomings of the basel iii market risk capital framework. In july 2009 the basel committee on banking supervision addressed the. Following the 200708 global financial crisis gfc, bcbs and other regulatory bodies studied the global regulatory framework in an effort to understand what caused or contributed to systemic breakdowns in markets during that period. Notably, dipak was a senior trader on the xva desk during the financial crisis. There has been a lot of discussion on how frtb will define whether a book is a banking book or a trading book. Criteria for trading banking book boundary include instrument structure, accounting treatment, availability of prices, portfolio, desk, hedge. As a global professional services company, we offer financial. Review of the trading book or frtb are designed to address basel 2. Aug 07, 2016 questions to think about how will the trading desk structure under frtb would differ from the existing volcker trading desk structure at banks.
Trading book banking book boundary the new regulation lists instruments presumed to be in the trading book art. All other instruments must be included in the banking book. Differences between interest rate risk irr in the banking and. Dipak was also responsible for frtb implementation for the business sitting on cross business committees, industry working groups and initiatives. The new boundary between the trading book and banking book which will limit the potential for regulatory arbitrage. A trading book is the portfolio of financial instruments held by a brokerage or bank.
Frtb prescribes a new framework for the segregation of the banking and trading books that involves strict definitions and constraints on movements across the boundary. The major overhaul of market risk capital regime is. Frtb demands a clear segregation of banking book and trading book instruments. A financial instrument is any contract that gives rise to both a. The frtb rules pose significant challenges for banks, which will be required to reconsider. Sep 26, 2017 why banks trading books are new target of rules. Reassignments are more difficult, so it is critical that banks get it right the first time. Is there light at the end of the trading books tunnel.
Trading instruments are presumed to be saleable at some, quantifiable price within a short timeframe 10 days under basel 2 and 2. It offered a degree of choice over how banks would like their assets to be classified and subsequently regulated. The proposal outlines a prescriptive list of instruments and hedging positions that shallshall not. Through the frtb rules, bcbs is seeking, for example, to establish a more objective boundary between the. There is a clear criterion for assigning instruments to the. Banks have to prove, that fair valued positions are not held with trading intent or do not hedge positions held with trading intent to exclude them from the trading book art. The trading bookbanking book boundary industry supports the committees pursuit to strengthen the definition and implementation of the boundary between the trading book and the banking book, and to reduce the risks of regulatory arbitrage. Basel iv revised trading and banking book boundary for. Frtb framework for trading boundary management frtb prescribes a new framework for the segregation of the banking and trading books that involves strict definitions and constraints on movements to read the rest of the article, please download the paper by completing form.
Finalised in january 2016 as the minimum capital requirements for market risk, it aims to address a. While car gives guidelines on how to divide instruments between the trading book and the banking book, frtb establishes a boundary between the trading book and the banking book, clearly setting out which instruments must be included or excluded from the trading book, with the intention of reducing. Program issues and impacts impact of the trading bookbanking book boundary regulators are establishing a more objective boundary to mitigate capital arbitrage between the regulatory trading. Rbc25 boundary between the banking book and the trading book.
Throughout his 17year tenure at ubs, dipak has occupied roles within technology, middle office, and front office. Questions to think about how will the trading desk structure under frtb would differ from the existing volcker trading desk structure at banks. The frtb was subsequently devised to tackle a number of structural flaws in the framework that were not addressed by basel 2. Details of positions in the banking book that, under the new regime, will need to be captured as trading book positions are shown in figure 1. Revise the boundary between the trading book and the banking book overhaul the ima to focus on tail risk, and. Instruments comprise financial instruments, foreign exchange fx, and commodities. This chapter sets out the instruments to be included in the trading book which are subject to market risk capital requirements and those to be. The primary issue with the above framework has been a lack of clear demarcation of boundary between the two books, which in the past enabled banks to shift assets to the trading book from the banking book prior to the financial crisis due to lower capital requirements and then do the reverse post financial crisis due to massive loss in. Dipak was also responsible for frtb implementation for the business sitting on. A revised boundary between the trading book and banking book the final rules establish a more objective boundary that serves to reduce incentives to arbitrage between the banking book and trading book, especially arbitrage in regulatory capital requirements between the two books. Frtb is a regulation issued by the basel committee on banking supervision bcbs, a committee of banking supervisory authorities established in 1974. Frtb has recommended stricter guidelines for banks to switch from a banking book to a trading book and vice versa. On 14 january 2016 the bcbs published the frtb rules which aim to standardise the treatment of market risk internationally and impose stricter global capital requirements.
823 482 220 1169 1464 486 714 559 40 1477 519 25 559 928 800 871 267 1604 1478 435 363 1583 935 1067 958 350 334 1393 637 1168 879 1431 828 742 588 1320 147